April 25, 2012

On Style & Sustainability

Copa Del Rey 2009. La Liga 2009. Champions League 2009. Spanish SuperCup 2009. UEFA SuperCup 2009. Club World Cup 2009. La Liga 2010. Spanish SuperCup 2010. La Liga 2011. Champions League 2011. Spanish SuperCup 2011. UEFA Supercup 2011. Club World Cup 2011.

I don’t know about you, but just reading that makes me dizzy. It doesn’t stop at a loss. Or a tournament. Or even an entire season.

What this team has given us in the Guardiola era, what we have been extremely privileged to witness, to celebrate and to take pride in as supporters of this club, is far gone and beyond being incredible. There aren’t words for it. Our club has been, for over three years now, the best club on the planet and arguably the best of all time. That it has lasted this long is astonishing in itself. It was never going to last forever.

Not that I’m saying it’s over.

What I am saying is that you have to look at things from the bigger picture. We can stop at this loss or at the one to Real Madrid last weekend, and we can say that it went wrong because of this and that, and that Guardiola should have done this and that, and if only this and if only that, but in the end none of that matters.

Because Barca is not invincible. These players have limits. And this is where those limits have caught up with them.

Barca has been playing the same way for four years now. The first three were teeming with success. This fourth one, not as much. So we start to lambast the style. It’s getting old, it’s been figured out, we need a plan B.

I see so many people criticize Guardiola and lament that Barca has had no plan B, but I don’t see any of them attempting to suggest exactly what this plan B should be. What style do you really expect, or want, Barca to play other than its own attacking, passing philosophy? The one that this club takes so much pride in, the one that the club took so much time and trouble to implement and develop, the only one that all the players who have and will come through this club’s academy are trained to play –  this academy that has been absolutely mind-blowing in its success at raising talent?

The evidence of the importance of this style and keeping true to it, and the fruit that it yields, is right there. We’ve been witnessing it firsthand for years. And this is why you have to look at the bigger picture, why you absolutely cannot stop now and say it needs to change. The thirteen trophies this club has won in the space of four years came about thanks to that style. Thirteen out of a possible eighteen, with a nineteenth still in play – it is too enormous a figure to let the two trophies recently let slip demand that we abandon the style.

Especially because you have to look at things from other angles. Or rather, from every angle. One is that no one can get everything right a hundred percent of the time. We can go back and talk about signings that shouldn’t have been made and ones that should have, players that shouldn’t have been sold and players that weren’t given the chances they deserved at the club, but in the end, most of this is acceptable. Because these mistakes will always happen, at every club and at every time. To expect otherwise is ridiculous. If you were looking for infallibility, you came to the wrong place.

Another is the physical condition of the team. The previous three seasons have been enormously successful, but they have also been enormously taxing. The more trophies the team wins the more trophies it gets to compete for, which means the more matches it has to play. This in turn means a huge toll on player fitness. Especially at a team like ours. Players like Messi, Xavi and Iniesta, players who are Barca’s heroes, are ones that at many other clubs would have been deemed too small and scrawny to be able to make it in the game, as they and their coaches have pointed out. This club’s advance to placing technique ahead of physicality has meant the rise of some fantastic players, but ones with lesser endurance.

Most of the team is small and injury prone. Several of them are getting old as well. All have been the victims of a horribly grueling match schedule. Before every Champions League draw Guardiola has only wished for Barca to be drawn against a team not too far way, as travel has always made the team suffer. This season moreso as Barca’s away form has been a far cry from their dominance of matches at home. Guardiola has resorted to having the team travel to away venues one or two days before, something they have never had to do before. And as the season is pulling to an end, the team is even tired at Camp Nou.

That is, those of them that are left.

When everyone is fit, Barca’s squad is still small. This season, the team has been injury plagued like never before. They lost a starting forward in David Villa in December. This counts for something. The pillar of our left flank, Eric Abidal, was distressingly forced to bow out of the season in need of a liver transplant. This counts for something. The long-term injuries of Afellay and Fontas, even if they are less important players, count for something. The frequent, incessant injuries of crucial players like Xavi, Iniesta, Puyol, Pique, Alexis and Cesc all count for something.

They don’t just count for something. They count for something huge. This season in particular, the team has been fatigued and injury plagued to a drastic extent. Are we forgetting that at one point Barca had no more than thirteen fit first team players? That almost every time a player has returned from an injury, it’s only been for two others to be sidelined in his place? I doubt that at any point in the season Guardiola has even had the same squad to choose from for two weeks in a row.

It’s not about the style being flawed. It’s about the team not being able to carry it out properly. It’s about players being unfit and out of form, players being unable to run as much they need to or pass the way that they need to or give as much as they need to, or simply being unable to play at all.

After last night’s game against Chelsea, I am unconcerned with the Champions League. The image in my head is Pique colliding with Victor and then not moving, and what I want is to know that he’s okay. The image in my head is Messi looking completely exhausted all night, and what I want is to make him sleep for a week. The image in my head is Xavi looking tired and in pain while still racking up more passes than the entire Chelsea team, and what I want is for Barca to able to rest him for the remainder of the season, even though the team needs him.

It goes without saying that this applies everywhere else, not just last night’s match. Tito’s empty seat on the bench week after week, Guardiola losing his head and cursing on the pitch after Alexis picked up an umpteenth injury, Villa looking dazed in a wheelchair with his wrapped leg propped up before him, Abidal continuing to train with the team right up until he was hospitalized for surgery – these are the images that endure, and the ones that are most concerning. Seeing Abidal come out of his transplant all right is more important than seeing Xavi make the right pass or Messi make the right finish. The team has been through more than its share of pain this season, and things must be kept in perspective.

When it comes down to it, falling short in the two major competitions has had to do with the fact that the squad, although hugely talented, is small and fatigued to begin with and has further been chopped down into limited pieces of a puzzle that Guardiola has had to attempt to piece back together. Injuries have broken the squad both physically and mentally and Guardiola has been under the enormous burden of figuring out how to go on after that. Figuring out what is going to happen to the left flank without Abidal, and who can play at centerback when both centerbacks are injured, and how much can Xavi give anymore at the age and condition he’s in, and who is going to attack alongside Messi when Alexis is injured, and is it better to play Tello or Cuenca in their inexperience rather than start Pedro or Cesc in their dubious form? And on and on and on, I don’t have to tell you.

A lot of us like to think we know a lot about how all this should be done, about how to plug in the holes and who to play where, but the truth is that it isn’t simple at all. I, for one, would not have traded places with Pep for the world. And after the thirteen trophies he’s already led this team to in such a short space of time, I think he deserves from us all to trust and admit that he kinda, sorta knows what he’s doing. It’s an enormous task he’s had this season, more than any of the three previous ones, and frankly, I don’t see that he’s done too bad of a job with it.

We made it to the semi final of the Champions League for an all-time record fifth year in a row. We fought far and hard for the Liga. We’re in the final of the Copa Del Rey. And before any of this, we already picked up two Supercups at the beginning of the season and the Club World Cup in December. Not a bad season at all, and a far cry from one that demands for the club to discard its style and come up with a new one. After all, this style is what defines Barca and if we’re going to die, we’re going to die doing what we believe in.

Let’s not let the success of recent years blind us into a false sense of invincibility or entitlement. It’s a game. You win and you lose. This has been our turn to lose a little. We still have a hell of a lot to be proud of.


  1. +100000000000000000
    Completely agree and this post made me cry a little.

    <3 visca el barça <3

  2. Excellent piece. I agree with almost everything except the "Plan B" rejection.

    Plan B doesnt mean defensive football it means having a variety to what you are doing. If Barcelona played for another 45 minutes I doubt they would have scored last night, cause the shape/pattern was set. Barcelona were passing it around but not at tempo and not with penetration. Lack of central defenders for Chelsea wasnt exposed cause they were only being tested on floor in tight/compact areas.

    Having Zlatan was that Plan B. Im not saying he should have stayed, NO.

    Pep recognized that and hence went for Zlatan.

    Having a bigger target man as an option would not mean you lump balls up only but it means you have the option to mix things up a little bit so you're not predictable when you cant break the opposition down.

    1. Zlatan would have fixed the tempo? No. Barca lacked that because the season has exhausted them, which is my point. Zlatan would not have changed this. He had the potential to offer variety, but during his time here he did not. So there is no use talking about that now. And Pep did not "go after Zlatan" the way you say. Villa was the first choice. The club spent months going after Villa that summer before suddenly, and to everyone's shock, swerving for Zlatan instead and this is down to two things: 1) Valencia's demand for more money for Villa than Barca was willing to pay, and more importantly, 2) Man City's move for Eto'o falling through.

      Guardiola's main concern that season was getting rid of Eto'o. He insisted on it. When the transfer period was coming to a close and Eto'o still didn't have a suitor, the club needed to act fast to make a move that would both offload & replace him. A trade with Valencia was not an option as they desperately needed the money - the following summer they agreed on the spot to sell Villa to Barca for 10 million less than their initial asking price - so the Ibra deal was struck. No one saw it coming. And sure the prospect was exciting, but it was soon clear what a mistake it was.

      I wrote a little bit about this at the time: http://barcelista.blogspot.com/2010/07/barcas-striker-issue.html

      I doubt having Zlatan last night would have made more of a difference than say, having Villa. Again, it is the injuries that have taken the greatest toll on Barca.

  3. I's rather loose a 1000 times with Barça style than win with the ugly horrendous Chelsea football.
    Yes, what this team has given us is priceless and yesterday I could see evidence of this:
    After watching the match at a friend's home I took a subway train full of supporters coming back from the stadium. It was like a funeral, but the guy standing by my side was texting on his phone: "We'll rise again" and the guy on the other side was texting: "I'm proud of this team". Lots of them were texting and I'm sure all messages were similar. When you have been a Barça supporter for more than 30 years, like me, and you know how Barça supporters used to be after a defeat you realize what an amazing thing this Pep team has achieved... The entire stadium singing the anthem at the end of the match after a defeat? WOW! That is priceless. Yes, we believe in our team.

  4. A great essay and one that captures the essence of what makes Barca great. I know it's been a tough go this season but still there is nothing to be ashamed of, and a lot of potential for the future. Forever Barca!

  5. Excellent essay and well captured. What the advocates of plan B failed to tell us is how do u play against a parking the bus(extremely defensive team) team ???? No team in world football have countered plan A even at parking the bus, its a one of thing.. Always and forever a culé... Forca Barca

  6. The loss was heartbreaking but we can never win every time just as this article is saying. In 2010 after the loss to Inter I felt the same way but you know what we bounced back very strongly the next season and won the league and champions league.